People often say the Buddha didn’t take sides on big questions — like whether the universe is eternal or not. Because of that, some thought he avoided taking a stand on anything. Some got frustrated and called him indecisive. Others admired him for being open-minded.
But both groups missed the point.
The Buddha didn’t waste time on debates that didn’t help people suffer less. He focused on what really mattered: how to live well. And on that, he was crystal clear.
He taught that unskillful actions — the ones that lead to suffering — include killing, stealing, cheating, lying, harsh speech, gossip that stirs up division, empty chatter, greed, hatred, and wrong thinking. Skillful actions are the opposite: honesty, kindness, generosity, peace, and wisdom.
Killing, especially, was never okay. Someone once asked if there was ever anything it was right to kill. His answer? Anger. That’s it. He never approved of killing any living being. In fact, when a monk told an executioner to kill “compassionately,” the Buddha expelled him from the community. Even suggesting such a thing went against his teaching.
He told his followers that even if they were attacked, they shouldn’t let anger take over. Instead, they should stay calm, speak kindly, and radiate compassion — even toward the people harming them.
When the Buddha gave moral guidelines to everyday people, he didn’t allow for loopholes. The first precept — not to kill — was meant to protect all beings. If you keep it, you offer safety to others and peace to yourself. But if you start making excuses — like “I’ll only kill if I feel threatened” — that protection falls apart.
This ties directly to karma. Unwholesome intentions bring suffering; wholesome intentions bring happiness. If you don’t kill, you don’t create new causes for your own life to be cut short. You might still face the results of past actions, but at least you’re not digging the hole deeper.
The Buddha said virtue is your greatest treasure. People can steal your possessions, but they can’t steal your goodness. And when your goodness is strong and steady, it shields you from the inside out.
Even if you don’t believe in karma or rebirth, the Buddha still said it’s worth living this way. He told people that if you always choose kind, honest actions, you’ll live with a clear conscience — and that’s priceless.
So yes, the Buddha took a stand: no killing, no stealing, no lying. Period.
But today, some leaders say it’s their duty to kill or lie to keep others safe. Even some Buddhist teachers try to argue that the Buddha must’ve allowed exceptions. But he never taught a “just war” idea. No soldier has ever truthfully said, “I killed with the Buddha’s blessing.” That’s one of the most powerful things about Buddhism — and we shouldn’t twist it to fit our compromises.
Some people point to kings or later teachers who went to war and say, “See? Buddhism allows it.” But just because a king who called himself Buddhist fought a war doesn’t mean the Buddha approved.
Others say, “Well, the Buddha didn’t tell kings to stop fighting, so maybe he was okay with it.” But in the Buddha’s teaching, silence only meant consent in small things — like accepting a meal. Most of the time, silence was just being polite. For example, when a soldier asked about heavenly rewards for dying in battle, the Buddha stayed quiet at first. But when pressed again and again, he finally said:
“If a warrior goes into battle thinking, ‘May these people be destroyed,’ and dies with that thought, he’s reborn in a hellish place. To believe otherwise is a wrong view — and wrong views lead to suffering.”
The soldier broke down in tears — not because the Buddha was cruel, but because he realized he’d been misled.
The Buddha was careful when speaking to kings. They had power, but not always wisdom. One king even asked how to attack his neighbors — clearly missing the point. Even King Pasenadi, who respected the Buddha deeply, was often slow to understand. But the Buddha kept guiding him patiently.
Once, he told Pasenadi to imagine four mountains rolling in from every direction, crushing everything. “What should you do?” he asked. The king replied, “Live in line with the Dharma.” The Buddha agreed — aging and death are rolling toward us just like those mountains.
Another time, Pasenadi said:
“People who act badly — in body, speech, or mind — leave themselves unprotected. Even if they have huge armies, they’re still vulnerable. But people who act well — even without armies — are safe, because real protection comes from within.”
Pasenadi didn’t always live up to this, but it left its mark. When another king invaded and was later captured, Pasenadi could have killed him. Instead, he spared his life. It’s hard not to see the Buddha’s influence there.
The Buddha also taught:
“If you kill, you invite someone to kill you. If you conquer, you invite someone to conquer you. If you insult, you invite insult. In this cycle of action, the plunderer is plundered in turn.”
Even Pasenadi, slow as he was, understood the lesson.
The real question is: why don’t we?
Link: https://wisdomtea.org/2025/09/18/no-killing-no-excuses/
Wisdom Tea 